News

How can you tell if steel is reusable?

The construction sector is undergoing a revolution: that of reuse. Steel, with its exceptional durability and ability to be dismantled without losing its properties, is the ideal candidate for the circular economy.

However, unlike a new product leaving the factory with its 3.1 certificate, steel from deconstruction raises a critical question: how can its structural safety be guaranteed? Here are the essential steps to determine whether steel can be reused.

The "resource" assessment: the visual inspection

Before any laboratory analysis, everything begins on the deconstruction site. Reusable steel must first pass the test of physical inspection.

  • Surface condition: superficial rust is acceptable. On the other hand, deep corrosion with section loss (pitting or lamination) often disqualifies the element for load-bearing structural functions.

  • Deformations: profiles (IPN, HEA) must show no warping, twisting, or visible residual deflection.

  • Human-induced alterations: we look for unauthorized drill holes, welds from secondary equipment, or torch cuts that may have weakened the part.

Traceability and documentary research

The availability of the original building’s health record is a major asset for validating reuse potential. In this context, the year of construction provides a valuable first indication of the likely steel grade. This documentary research also relies on as-built drawings, which are essential for accurately identifying the loads the element carried during its first life.

Technical testing: proof through data

To reintegrate steel into a new structural calculation, the engineer needs guaranteed values. This is where laboratory tests come in.

Chemical analysis (spectrometry)

It is important to check the weldability of the steel, especially for older structures. With spectrometry, the carbon equivalent (Ceq) is measured in particular. Excessively high carbon or phosphorus content makes welding risky (risk of cold cracking).

Mechanical testing

During mechanical tests, specimens are taken from a representative sampling of the deposit to measure:

  • The yield strength (Re) : the threshold value before permanent deformation.

  • The tensile strength (Rm) : the maximum load supported.

  • The elongation after fracture (A%) : to check the metal's ductility.

Impact test (Charpy)

The Charpy impact test is essential for structures exposed to low temperatures or impact loads. It checks the steel’s ability to absorb energy without brittle fracture at a given temperature (e.g. 27 Joules at 0°C).

The regulatory framework: CTICM, the reference guide

In France and across Europe, the reuse of steel is now governed by strict protocols such as the CTICM Guide (Technical Industrial Centre for Metal Construction). This document defines:

  1. The performance classes of the stock.

  2. The number of tests to be carried out depending on tonnage.

  3. The method for recalculating safety factors.

Summary: green light for reuse

Green Signal 🟢Orange Signal 🟠Red Signal 🔴
Identified grade (e.g., S235).Surface corrosion that can be treated by sandblasting.Cracks at the welds.
Perfect geometry.No original documentation available (tests required).Steel that has been exposed to fire.
Carbon equivalent < 0.45%.Previous dynamic use (overhead crane).Visible plastic deformation.

In conclusion

Knowing whether steel can be reused is a mix of field observation and scientific rigor. While the cost of testing may seem high, it is largely offset by material savings and environmental benefits (one tonne of reused steel saves around 1.5 to 2 tonnes of CO2).

Ready to integrate reused steel into your projects? Contact us to discuss your project

Frequently asked questions

Is a visual inspection sufficient to declare steel suitable for reuse in a structure?

A visual inspection is a first step, but it is not sufficient to establish the performance required for a new structural use. Traceability, geometry, condition and material properties must also be considered. The analyses support the requalification process; the suitability of the element also depends on the project, its design and the applicable technical requirements.

Why analyze the composition of steel intended for reuse?

Chemical composition helps verify the consistency of the steel grade and assess certain parameters relevant to potential welding, including the carbon equivalent calculated according to the selected formula. However, interpretation depends on the thickness, process and implementation conditions. An isolated chemical value does not constitute general authorization for reuse or welding. Learn more about steel analysis.

Which mechanical tests can document the performance of reused steel?

Tensile tests can provide information on yield strength, tensile strength and elongation. Depending on the new use and the applicable standard, a Charpy impact test can supplement the characterization at a specified temperature. The selection and number of specimens must be based on a program representative of the source stock; the results do not replace structural verification.

Does visible corrosion automatically rule out the reuse of a steel element?

Surface oxidation must be distinguished from deterioration affecting the cross-section, connections or integrity of the element. The location, depth and extent of the corrosion must be assessed in relation to the new use. A decision requires technical criteria and, where appropriate, additional measurements; appearance alone cannot systematically justify either accepting or rejecting the component.

How should the traceability and sampling of a stock of steel elements be organized?

The origin of the elements, their usage history and any modifications they have undergone make it possible to establish consistent batches and prepare a characterization program. Each sample must remain linked to the elements it represents. Professional recommendations provide a framework for requalification and the associated responsibilities. Consult CTICM resources on steel reuse.